Get the falsies look without the hassle. The quickest way to add some drama to your makeup looks? The best volumizing mascaras lift, lengthen, fan, and thicken even the shortest, finest lashes to give you all-day flutter that rivals lash extensions. More and more formulas are even infused with oils and conditioning ingredients (such as castor oil and pro-vitamin B5) to soften lashes—and nip the chances of midday clumping, or a brittle or flaky cast in the bud. And, with innovations in wand shape and size, it’s easier to achieve volume without piling on the product. Now, helping you find the right mascara is where we come in. Below, we gathered our favorite volumizing mascaras to transform your lashes in just a few swipes. Lights, camera, drama!
Our Top Volumizing Mascaras
Best Overall: Armani Beauty Vertigo Lift Mascara, $32
Best Smudge-Proof: KJH.brand Microscara, $26
Best Lengthening: L’Oréal Paris Voluminous Lash Paradise Volume Mascara, $14
Best Conditioning: Nars Notorious Mascara, $29
Best Overall: Armani Beauty Vertigo Lift Mascara
Why it’s worth it: When it’s a 2026 Best of Beauty winner, can you truly be surprised it’s also our best overall pick? Armani Vertigo Lift Mascara won drumroll, please, best volumizing mascara for its bold, intense color and precision applicator that grips onto each individual lash, separates, and coats them in a long-wearing formula. A key ingredient is arginine amino acids (building blocks of keratin), which help strengthen the lash hairs—lending them a weightless and not-at-all-brittle feel.
If your lashes are on the shorter or thinner side, the Infinity Loop brush is designed somewhat like a fine-tooth comb for lashes, complete with tightly spaced micro-bristles to catch and grip onto the stubbiest, most stubborn hairs, and distribute product evenly. No clumps to be seen here.
Best Smudge-Proof: KJH.brand Microscara
Why it’s worth it: Micro wand, maximum impact—that’s the philosophy behind the KJH.brand Microscara, and we can vouch that it holds up. If you look at any of Katie Jane Hughes’ celebrity clients like Dua Lipa or Molly Gordon, you’ll immediately notice their defined top and bottom lashes. That’s thanks to this mascara’s miniature wand that precisely reaches each lash and coats them with a smudge-proof formula, even the elusive inner-corner hairs. The mascara has a host of hydrating ingredients like shea butter, glycerin, and castor oil that soften the lashes for a more flexible finish. The tubing formula also takes your lashes from a subtle wisp to a dramatic flutter with minimal product—meaning less of a risk of smudging on the top and bottom lashes. We’re big fans of tubing mascaras at Allure, so this formula’s easy-removal factor is another big bonus.
Best Separating: Merit Clean Volume Mascara
Why it’s worth it: If you have sensitive eyes that are prone to watering and irritation, this 2021 Best of Beauty Award winner is ophthalmologist-tested, safe for contact lens wearers, and feels extra lightweight on the lashes. In lieu of traditional waxes, the “clean*” tubing formula is made using a film-forming polymer popular in Japanese beauty for its flexible, easy-to-remove coating that doesn’t weigh down the lashes. This ingredient also helps resist moisture, including sweat and humidity, so whether you’re tearing up at a wedding or running errands on a hot day, there’s no need to worry about smudging. Plus, the precision wand smoothly combs through lashes without tugging and separates lashes for volume with a natural lift. (*Editor’s note: While we are generally dubious about clean beauty, let the record show that Merit does meet Allure clean beauty standards.)
Best Conditioning: Nars Notorious Mascara
Why it’s worth it: If lash health is equally as important to you as lash length, Nars Notorious Mascara is infused with argan oil to condition your lashes and prevent dryness. The formula uses 3D film-flex polymers, which wrap each lash in a flexible coat instead of a more brittle cast, meaning less flaking and discomfort. The wavy, multi-length bristle brush catches each lash and comes with a pronged tip that fits into the inner corners of the eyes for an even distribution of product. Aside from black, this formula comes in a rich mahogany brown shade for more subtle lash definition.
Best Lengthening: L’Oréal Paris Voluminous Lash Paradise Volume Mascara
Why it’s worth it: If you want to be 100% sure every lash of yours gets lifted, curled, and lengthened, a mascara wand with over 200 soft bristles ought to do the trick. (And the $15 price tag is enticing, to say the least.) L’Oreal Paris’s Voluminous Lash Paradise Volume Mascara is also infused with rosehip oil—which is rich in essential fatty acids and antioxidants—to condition lashes, help prevent breakage, and offer more comfortable wear. This mascara comes in five shades, including Blackest Black, Black, Black Brown, Mystic Black, and Latte Brown—so you can tailor your level of intensity from more natural to super intense.
Best Brown: YSL Beauty Lash Clash Extreme Volume Mascara
Why it’s worth it: YSL Beauty’s Lash Clash Extreme Volume Mascara is our go-to for big, bold, and party-ready lashes. The secret is in the multifaceted formula—volume-building, lengthening, and jet-black—and its oversized yet easy-to-maneuver wand. New York City-based makeup artist Sara Talias also swears by this thickening recipe. “The brush is great for building volume with extra coats of mascara and allows you to grab all the lashes,” she says. Its extra-large brush has a double conical shape—a wide cone shape with a tapered tip—featuring 260 dense bristles that hold a generous amount of product, coating each lash in pigment from root to tip.
We also love that this two-time Best of Beauty Award-winning mascara is offered in chocolatey brown—a deeply underrated hue for more natural looks. Oh, and if your definition of “natural” is a bit outside of the box, you can grab this formula in vibrant blue, too.
Best Tubing: Tarte Tartelette XL Tubing Mascara
Why it’s worth it: If you loved the original Tartelette Tubing formula, why not take it up a notch with the Tarte Tartelette XL Tubing Mascara? This Best of Beauty Award-winning formula has all of the benefits of the original, but is infused with a TLC complex that consists of niacinamide, peptides, panthenol, and biotin to help thicken and lift the lashes for a more dramatic look. For an even fuller finish, this formula uses carnauba wax, a vegetable wax derived from the Brazilian palm tree that creates a firm yet flexible coat around the lashes, which helps the lashes hold their curl while making them appear thicker and more lifted. This formula also conditions and boosts shine with shea butter and castor oil for a your-lashes-but-better finish.
Best for Subtle Volume: Benefit Fan Fest Mascara
Why it’s worth it: If you’ve long resorted to falsies for a wispy, fanned-out lash look—but don’t always have the patience to put them on—Benefit’s Fan Fest Mascara is bound to become a regular in your rotation. This separating, volumizing formula lasts all day, fanning out lashes with a thoughtfully curved brush that follows their natural contours for fullness—without an over-the-top, va-va-voom finish, and that’s intentional. “The more mascara you have on your lashes, the more likely it is to clump,” explained Maggie Ford Danielson, director of brand outreach at Benefit Cosmetics, which is why you only need a few swipes of this product for subtle yet feathery volume. It’s nourishing, too, with pro-vitamin B5, a conditioning agent that keeps the lashes from getting dry or brittle. Cranberry wax and rice wax also coat and condition every itty-bitty lash and “act as thickening agents for further volume,” says LA-based cosmetic chemist Amanda Lam. In other words, Fan Fest is the ideal everyday mascara to swipe on and go.
Allure Best of Beauty 2026: Eyes Winners
We Test Tons of Tubing Mascaras—Here Are Our Favorites
7 Best Eyelash Curlers for a Longer, Lifted Look
Done reading? Now, watch your favorite stars take you through their beauty routines and appointments:
Don’t forget to follow Allure on Instagram, Twitter, and TikTok, or subscribe to our newsletter to stay up to date on all things beauty.
